www.futureofhumanity.org
Featured Post
Intentional Ignorance

November 6, 2012

I wrote this essay to offer some essential information about our world and the future of our species, adding my voice to the many cries of alarm over the environmental crisis (lately reaching criticality). [More…]

Receive Post Notices
Tag Cloud
100% Renewables 350.org AAAS abundance action Age of Earth Al Bartlett Animal Rights Annihilation of Nature Anthropocene Anti-climate change Anti-Science assertion bee colony collapse bee die-off Biodiversity Biodiversity loss Biomass battery of Earth biosphere birth control carbon tax carbon taxes Carrying capacity Change Changing planet Children's Climate Crusade Citizens Climate Lobby Citizens United civilization claims Clean energy climate Climate action Climate Change Climate Desk Climate Impacts Accelerating Climate resilience climate science Climate Skeptics Climate Summit CO2 collapse Collapse assessment Conflicting Views consequences Conservation conservative thought contacting leaders Conversion from fossil fuels COP-21 credentials curiosity Debates decimation Defending the Climate democracy depletion Earth earth day Earth Full Earth system Ecocide ecological footprint Ecological imperialism Economics Economic self-interest ecosystem collapse Ecosystem services Education of women End of nature energy energy conservation Energy facts energy policy environment Environmental concern Environmental Ed Environmental Impacts environmental law Environmental reform equilibrium essays Ethics Exponential curve Extinction extinctions facts Failures to act Family planning Fertility food FossilFuels fossil fuels Future future expectations Genetic preservation global overshoot Global Population Speakout GlobalWarming global warming Government Action Government leadership government policy Government warnings grass roots Great photo collection Greenhouse Gas Emissions Greenhouse gases Green revolution Growth Myth Human-invasive species Human development human domination Human fertility human history human impacts Humanity Humanity's worst act Humanity system Human nature I=PAT immigration Impactful message inequality intentional ignorance IPCC KeystonePipeline Leadership life-support system Life in the Universe Lobbying for the Climate MAHB male chauvinism Mass Extinction Meaning of humanity media Military leadership NASA Natural Resources nature nature's services Nature's Trust Nature Services new politics non-equilibrium Nuclear Energy Nuclear Failures Nuclear Licensing nuclear safety Nuclear Waste Objectivity Oil Organic energy Overpopulation overpopulation consequences Paris action Paris Global Warming Meeting Peoples Climate March Planetary boundaries Planetary conditions Planet Under Pressure PMC policy political action political failures political protests Political support political systems politics Population population; employment; job creation Population Control population growth Preparing for Climate Change President Obama pricing carbon Problem Summary proof protecting nature PV Rationality reason reducing CO2 reducing fossil emissions Reducing fossil fuel combustion reform religion renewable economics Renewable Energy renewables republican brain resource depletion Resources for learning responsibility Reversing climate change Risk saving humanity science science denial Scientific warnings ScientistWarnings sex and global warming Societal collapse Solar solar economics solar electric solar energy solar thermal Species species extinction Status of women Steps we can take Sustainability SustainableValues Taking action teams of specialists TED talks Terrorist threats The Big Greens the big picture The Future The White House thought processes Turning Point UCS Uncontrolled growth university education UN Report Vanishing wilderness water Wildlife wind wind energy Women equality Worldview Wrecked Ocean WWF

Resource Realities

Thanks to Bob Walker, President of the Population Institute, for quickly responding to a particularly mendacious column put out recently by the notorious George Will. As Bob successfully points out, the arguments Will makes are innovative, cutting edge and perhaps even moderately convincing , “assuming, of course, you are still living in the previous century.” Will titles his column “Doomsday Predictions Never Come Close.”

Walker writes:

When it comes to the environment, George Will is a classic conservative. As evidenced by his latest column (“Doomsday Predictions Never Come Close”), his views never change. They remain forever frozen in time, along with his facts and figures. The polar icecaps and all the glaciers could melt, the oceans could rise by 20 feet, and he would still be saying, ‘ We’re having some hot weather. Get over it.”

Several weeks ago, Will created a minor stir when he breezily dismissed any possible connection between climate change and the massive drought that has been afflicting half the country. He scoffed at the idea that anything had fundamentally changed. “I grew up in central Illinois in a house without air conditioning. What is so unusual about this?”

Well, like Will, I grew up in central Illinois in a house without air conditioning, but I never recall the corn fields looking like they had been microwaved. Nor do I rely upon my childhood memories when weighing matters of scientific record. When the scientists say that the country has endured the hottest decade on record or that the drought is the worst in over 50 years, I don’t beg to differ.

….

If George Will had written his column twelve years ago, it might have been deemed credible, but today it is just laughable. It’s as if record high temperatures, record droughts, record flooding, and record commodity prices count for nothing.

George Will, like many other climate and science-deniers, is trapped in a preconceived vision of how the world works, and nothing will change his ossified convictions. Leading scientists may be warning that human activities are breaching “planetary boundaries” and threatening posterity and the planet, but the world according to Will never changes.

Unfortunately, particularly for the poorest of the world’s urban poor, the world is changing. With wheat and soybean prices rising this summer to new heights, and wheat prices soaring once again, the world is dangerously close to its third food crisis in five years. Once again, the household budgets of those living on a $1 or $2 a day is being stretched to the breaking point.

….

George Will and other conservative intellectuals ignore such “doomsday” warnings, not because they lack supporting evidence, but because they do not comport with their long-held convictions. They should recall the wisdom of a more visionary conservative, Thomas Jefferson, who said:

“… laws and institutions must go hand in hand with the progress of the human mind. As that becomes more developed, more enlightened, as new discoveries are made, new truths discovered and manners and opinions change, with the change of circumstances, institutions must advance also to keep pace with the times.”

But George Will does not believe in keeping pace with the times… or the data. I guess it’s a case of willful denial.

I urge readers to read Walker’s Huffington Post article and form their own opinions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.